Re: What is your favourite film score?
Posted: Sat Dec 17, 2011 11:29 pm
...
The independent home for discussions on the English Chess scene.
https://ecforum.org.uk/
Alan Menkin did all those. the last one on the list is probably the best. Surprised to see no Bernard Hermann or John Williams mentions from what I can see, yet Nyman (the marmite of film composing) has been.James Byrne wrote:For a non-disney film I'd say Braveheart.
But for Disney films I liked the following soundtracks the most:
Lion King
Pocahontus
Tarzan
Aladdin
Beauty & the Beast
Yeah, I'd forgotten 633 Squadron - possibly because I think of it as a theme tune rather than a film score as such. But one of the greats, all right - thank you Ron Goodwin.Kevin Thurlow wrote:633 Squadron and Great Escape are good. From TV, I suppose my favourites are Twin Peaks, Virginian and Rawhide.
While on the military theme there is some fine music supporting the dramatic battle sequence, the best one I've so far heard (interwoven very effectively with the film imagery) being Sir William Walton's from "The Battle of Britain". Quite extraordinary.John Clarke wrote:Yeah, I'd forgotten 633 Squadron - possibly because I think of it as a theme tune rather than a film score as such. But one of the greats, all right - thank you Ron Goodwin.Kevin Thurlow wrote:633 Squadron and Great Escape are good. From TV, I suppose my favourites are Twin Peaks, Virginian and Rawhide.
The Dam Busters (Eric Coates) would have to be pretty close too. Rousing where required, and melancholic as well when appropriate. Which prompts the question of what music Peter Jackson will use, if his own version of the story ever gets into production. I can't think of any other film where the theme has become quite so closely associated with its subject, to the extent where anything else seems almost inconceivable.
Much of the military film stuff tends to be a pastiche on Military Band music as opposed to having a genuinely new outlook which works in collaboration with the film. The tunes may well be good and the music have an uplifting feel but the music is not inherently unique and tends to be regurgitated militaria adapted to fit. Morricone on the other hand transformed the film score for western films and at the time had a refreshingly new outlook on the instrumentation. The main theme to The Great Escape is good because of its slightly quirky nature and a great tune.John Clarke wrote:Yeah, I'd forgotten 633 Squadron - possibly because I think of it as a theme tune rather than a film score as such. But one of the greats, all right - thank you Ron Goodwin.Kevin Thurlow wrote:633 Squadron and Great Escape are good. From TV, I suppose my favourites are Twin Peaks, Virginian and Rawhide.
The Dam Busters (Eric Coates) would have to be pretty close too. Rousing where required, and melancholic as well when appropriate. Which prompts the question of what music Peter Jackson will use, if his own version of the story ever gets into production. I can't think of any other film where the theme has become quite so closely associated with its subject, to the extent where anything else seems almost inconceivable.
Menken did Pocahontas, Aladdin and B&tB, yes, but not Lion King (composer for the songs was Elton John, and for the score was Hans Zimmer) or Tarzan (composer was Phil Collins for the songs and Mark Mancina for the score).Gavin Strachan wrote: ↑Sun Dec 18, 2011 10:53 amAlan Menkin did all those. the last one on the list is probably the best. Surprised to see no Bernard Hermann or John Williams mentions from what I can see, yet Nyman (the marmite of film composing) has been.James Byrne wrote:For a non-disney film I'd say Braveheart.
But for Disney films I liked the following soundtracks the most:
Lion King
Pocahontus
Tarzan
Aladdin
Beauty & the Beast