Bizarre oversight
Posted: Sun Jul 08, 2012 11:35 pm
A classic (if rather bizarre) example of chess blindness occurred at the County Chess Championships Finals yesterday. It was on one of the boards next to me in the U180 match between Middlesex and Yorkshire (both players will remain nameless here, though as the game scores will be posted somewhere it will be easy to look up if anyone really needs to know). I'm not sure of the exact position or move order, but the position was something like this (after a Scandinavian Defence opening):
I had briefly looked at the position before the Middlesex player's (Black's) last move (castling queenside) and thought to myself "that's a clever move, the complications might work out in Black's favour". I then turned back to concentrating on my own game. A few minutes later, I noticed the Yorkshire player (White) playing 1.Nxe5???? "Oops", I thought. "That's a point chalked up for Middlesex", but before I could turn back to concentrating on my own game, Black played 1...Bxb5+???? Somehow missing the much stronger move that was available...
Needless to say, this completely destroyed my own concentration. I struggled through the rest of my game, scraping a draw, and then went to analyse the game with my opponent. In the analysis room, I noticed the two players analysing a later position in the game (it was eventually drawn), and asked if they'd found any earlier improvements. Turned out they'd completely missed the winning move when going through the opening as well! I showed them what should have happened and the Yorkshire player (and some of his team-mates) seemed rather shocked and dumbfounded. The Middlesex player took it very well, and couldn't stop laughing for at least a minute (he doesn't normally miss things like that).
Totally bizarre, and I was seriously wondering if there was some reason the winning move couldn't have been played. The moral of the story, I suppose, is not to watch other people's games, but to concentrate on your own game. I've lost count of the number of times I've mentally 'won' positions on other people's boards next to me or near me while seeing my own position deteriorate, but I've never been as shocked by a series of moves as I was when seeing those moves played. Has anyone ever had that experience where the moves of another game put you off your own game?
I had briefly looked at the position before the Middlesex player's (Black's) last move (castling queenside) and thought to myself "that's a clever move, the complications might work out in Black's favour". I then turned back to concentrating on my own game. A few minutes later, I noticed the Yorkshire player (White) playing 1.Nxe5???? "Oops", I thought. "That's a point chalked up for Middlesex", but before I could turn back to concentrating on my own game, Black played 1...Bxb5+???? Somehow missing the much stronger move that was available...
Needless to say, this completely destroyed my own concentration. I struggled through the rest of my game, scraping a draw, and then went to analyse the game with my opponent. In the analysis room, I noticed the two players analysing a later position in the game (it was eventually drawn), and asked if they'd found any earlier improvements. Turned out they'd completely missed the winning move when going through the opening as well! I showed them what should have happened and the Yorkshire player (and some of his team-mates) seemed rather shocked and dumbfounded. The Middlesex player took it very well, and couldn't stop laughing for at least a minute (he doesn't normally miss things like that).
Totally bizarre, and I was seriously wondering if there was some reason the winning move couldn't have been played. The moral of the story, I suppose, is not to watch other people's games, but to concentrate on your own game. I've lost count of the number of times I've mentally 'won' positions on other people's boards next to me or near me while seeing my own position deteriorate, but I've never been as shocked by a series of moves as I was when seeing those moves played. Has anyone ever had that experience where the moves of another game put you off your own game?